When we decided to invite Ashley Elizabeth, a.k.a. Pelvis Costello, back to indie617 (don’t ask why), we knew we were asking for trouble. A few weeks back she joined Morning Glory and argued that Sam’s Town was the best Killers album and that recent-era Editors is justfinethankyouverymuch.

This morning (October 24) she was back on her business, rolling hard into Morning Glory to discuss the time Ryan Adams had to watch over her in Hampton Beach, what she’d buy Drake for his 32nd birthday (which is today), and which Strokes album is better, debut LP Is This It or the sophomore record Room On Fire.

Ashley swears that Room On Fire is the better Strokes album, and I rightfully defend Is This It as their finest effort.

An on-the-fly Twitter poll sided with me, as Is This It generated about 77 percent of the vote. What say you?

Hear her claims below.