Yes, Halloween fever has swept indie617 up in a swirl of October joy. In recent Quesdays we have raised the dead and gone trick or treating with our favorite musicians, but today, we’re getting all kinds of silly by asking: If your favorite band was a Halloween candy, what would they be?

And holy shit the answers were a good time. Check out the recap thread below, and most of this Quesday discussion was held over on Twitter.

@thejeffbartell: My Bloody Valentine as all pink and red Starburst…

@misschriss2789: Mac Demarco as Chiclets…

@AshleyElizabeth: The Killers would be Smarties. Straight up compacted sugar that is so sweet it burns off your tastebuds for a couple of hours at a time…

@jason_cervone: Going to go with the Clash as M&Ms. The number of different kinds represent the styles of music they tried to play, and while not all of them worked, what did makes them both legendary.

And that’s just a sample. Hit all the replies below.